Students in the original sample were reassessed 2 years later. Compared to young adolescents from schools not included in the original study, participants were more knowledgeable, had higher body esteem, and used fewer unhealthy weight management techniques. Cross-talk among control and treatment groups at the same school creates a major confound for controlled school-based studies. At least 22 studies have evaluated universal prevention interventions with middle-school children.
Killen et al. The intervention produced only modest increases in knowledge and no short-or long-term changes in attitudes or behaviors. At 2-year follow-up, the effect sizes of Weight Concerns for at-risk students in the preventive intervention and control classes were moderate.
Thus, the intervention may have been effective for high-risk students. McVey and Davis implemented a curriculum of six 1-hour lessons combining features of the HWR and SESC models for to year-old girls beginning the transition into adolescence. There were no significant differences in body satisfaction and eating attitudes between schools that received the intervention and schools that did not.
Among the girls who were not dieting or eating disordered at baseline, only 1 0. Promising results have also been reported in a series of studies using elements of the SESC model. For example, Steiner-Adair et al. This curriculum, called Full of Ourselves , consists of 70 activities, organized into eight units delivered across 2—4 months. Students learn assertion skills and learn how to be more supportive of one another. The curriculum also discusses issues related to prejudice about weight and teaches students to critically evaluate various cultural messages pertaining to gender, beauty, weight, and eating.
Students are encouraged to take active leadership roles in social-justice issues p. The girls are given the opportunity to work closely with trained adult mentors and to serve as mentors themselves for girls ages 9 to Among seventh-grade girls in 24 schools, significant pre-to postintervention effects were found on measures of eating disorder knowledge and weight-related body esteem, which were maintained at 6-month follow-up.
There were no apparent effects on weight management behavior. Universal prevention has been evaluated in at least 23 studies with high school students ages 14 through Four controlled studies of the HWR model with variations of the SESC model have produced positive pre-to postprogram changes, but the positive effects were limited to drive for thinness Wiseman et al.
Eating-disordered attitudes and behaviors are difficult to alter because they are strongly reinforced by a variety of family, peer, medical, and other cultural factors. Piran , an advocate of this approach, has demonstrated that systemwide changes can reduce eating disorders in the high-risk setting of an elite ballet school. Neumark-Sztainer, Sherwood, Coller, and Hannan designed a community-based intervention to prevent disordered eating among preadolescent girls, and randomized Girl Scout troop members into control and intervention groups.
The intervention consisted of six minute sessions focusing on media literacy and advocacy skills, with some training for troop leaders. At 3-month follow-up, the program demonstrated a positive influence on media-related attitudes and behaviors including internalization of sociocultural ideals, self-efficacy to impact weight-related social norms, and print media habits.
Unfortunately, manipulation of system or setting variables to prevent the development of eating disorders has not been well tested in other settings or by other researchers. A number of studies, usually focused on older adolescents or college students, have shown that interventions targeted at high-risk students can be effective. Because most of these studies included self-selected and older samples, extrapolation of their success to adolescents should be made cautiously. Stice, Trost, and Chase randomly assigned high school and college students to a dissonance treatment, a healthy weight management condition, or a waiting-list control.
With this approach, the participants were asked to help create a program to teach younger girls body acceptance and to avoid internalizing the thin-body ideal. The theory is that participating students will change their own attitudes and beliefs to better conform to the messages they are developing for the younger girls. At 6-month follow-up, the dissonance group had a sustained reduction in internalization of the thin ideal, but the effects for the other measures dissipated after the program body dissatisfaction or at 6-month follow-up negative affect and bulimic behavior.
If anything, the healthy weight intervention resulted in longer-term improvements in negative affect and bulimic symptoms. Results from other studies reporting the effects of both brief and more intense psycho p. Mann et al. At the posttest, intervention participants had slightly more symptoms of eating disorders than did controls. Franko found little benefit from a more intensive eight-session psychosocial support group, whereas Stice and Ragan and Springer, Winzelberg, Perkins, and Taylor found some positive effects of college courses on body image and disordered eating.
Studies of students with borderline symptoms of clinical disorders have also been promising. For instance, Kaminski and McNamara randomized at-risk female college students to a no-treatment control or a cognitive-behavioral group, and at 1-month follow-up the intervention group demonstrated significant improvements in weight management behavior, body satisfaction, and self-esteem, and less fear of negative evaluation.
These and more clinically focused studies show that intensive, targeted interventions can reduce risk factors, at least in the short term. Luce et al. Olmsted, Daneman, Rydall, Lawson, and Rodin randomly assigned adolescent girls with insulin-dependent diabetes to a psychoeducational program. At 6-month follow-up, significant reductions in body dissatisfaction, drive for thinness, dietary restraint, and eating concerns were observed.
Students participating in certain types of athletic activities can also be considered high risk, but there are no studies of adolescents with these characteristics.
The prevention of disordered eating is an important issue in public health. Many young girls and women, as well as boys, suffer from severe and potentially chronic problems with body image, eating, and various forms of unhealthy weight management.
In addition, efforts to combine prevention efforts for eating disorders and obesity are important, as some of the fundamental factors that influence disordered eating may also contribute to obesity. The data on the prevention of both eating disorders and cigarette smoking and other drug use Tobler et al. Universal prevention efforts with elementary school children have produced positive changes in the relevant knowledge and attitudes of students.
Programs that focus on changing factors with broad application, such as increasing self-esteem, creating a stronger sense of connection to peers and mentors, and transforming critical awareness into cultural change, have proved promising with middle school students, but it is unclear whether interventions using the HWR p.
High school students are a very difficult target audience for universal prevention, as evidenced by nine studies in five different countries producing no significant effects on attitudes and behaviors. Thus it remains unclear whether universal prevention interventions are effective for preventing eating disorders.
However, a dearth of universal prevention studies is different from a proven lack of effectiveness, particularly when well-designed studies of multidimensional interventions are rare.
Many questions remain about universal prevention programs, such as how these programs can have stronger and more long-lasting effects on risk factors, what the ideal age is for such interventions, what the advantages and disadvantages are of combined interventions, how to include environmental and family factors, and whether programs should be provided to both boys and girls in the same setting. The general lack of effectiveness of programs aimed at preventing eating disorders in adolescents also needs to be put in the context of substantial research done on prevention of substance abuse, high-risk sexual behavior, and juvenile delinquency and violence Nation et al.
In an extensive review, the authors concluded that effective prevention programs need to be comprehensive, include varied teaching methods, provide sufficient dosage, be theory driven, provide opportunities for positive relationships, be developmentally appropriate and socioculturally relevant, include outcome evaluation, and involve well-trained staff. Few of the eating disorder prevention studies meet all these characteristics. A number of studies have demonstrated that interventions targeting high-risk students can be effective, but because many of these studies focused on self-selected and older samples, caution is needed in generalizing the findings to adolescents.
Analyses of universal prevention studies suggest that the HWR model might work for high-risk students, but surprisingly little research has focused on students in high-risk settings. Although targeted interventions have proven effective, their effects are generally short-lived and specific to a few dimensions. The challenges in delivering targeted interventions, particularly to populations, are substantial. For example, in school settings, the identification and motivation for high-risk individuals to participate in interventions may be difficult.
All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the licence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of a title in Oxford Medicine Online for personal use for details see Privacy Policy and Legal Notice. Oxford Medicine Online. Publications Pages Publications Pages. Recently viewed 0 Save Search.
Dwight L. Evans Dwight L. Evans University of Pennsylvania Close. Edna B. Foa Edna B. Foa University of Pennsylvania Close.
Raquel E. Gur Raquel E. Gur University of Pennsylvania Close. Charles P. O'Brien Charles P. O'Brien University of Pennsylvania Close. Martin E. Seligman Martin E. Seligman University of Pennsylvania Close. Timothy Walsh B. Timothy Walsh Columbia University Close. Read More. Your current browser may not support copying via this button. Some clinicians have reported anecdotally that self-recovery is possible, although little scientific evidence from well-conducted studies is available to really determine the effectiveness of self-recovery.
Several published studies show that dropout rates were higher for self-help psychological interventions than for other treatment interventions that involved interaction with professionals experienced in treating eating disorders. Researchers have identified some indicators that may predict chances for a successful recovery. Individuals who are self-confident, realistic, and goal-oriented and who make early progress in therapy usually respond well to the overall treatment plan.
Individuals who begin treatment with a low body mass index, have a history of obesity, and show signs of depression may respond less well to therapy. Many situations and feelings can trigger bulimic behavior: extreme emotional distress, anxiety, depression, dieting, exposure to certain foods especially high-sugar or high-fat foods , or sudden dissatisfaction with body image.
People with bulimia nervosa have reported extreme mood changes before, during, and after binge eating and purging or nonpurging compensatory behavior. They have also reported feeling depressed or anxious before binge eating and then feeling temporary relief or even euphoria afterward. Merck Manual Professional Version. Engel S, et al. Bulimia nervosa in adults: Clinical features, course of illness, assessment, and diagnosis. Accessed Jan.
Davis H, et al. Pharmacotherapy of eating disorders. Current Opinion in Psychiatry. Eating disorders. National Alliance on Mental Illness. Rochester, Minn. Harrington BC, et al. Initial evaluation, diagnosis, and treatment of anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. American Family Physician. Herpertz-Dahlmann B. Treatment of eating disorders in child and adolescent psychiatry. Forman SF. Eating disorders: Overview of epidemiology, clinical features, and diagnosis.
Rienecke RD. Family-based treatment of eating disorders in adolescents: Current insights. Adolescent Health, Medicine and Therapeutics. Castillo M, et al.
Cultivate a positive view of yourself by repeating the truth about your body. Write down a list of things you like about your body.
Write each thing on a post it note and stick it around your house where you can see it every day, repeating each one out loud when you see it. Give yourself credit and encouragement on a daily basis, such as forgiving yourself when you make mistakes or have negative thoughts about your body. Build up your self-esteem. To help ensure that you have high self-esteem, first understand that low self-esteem often comes from experiencing a childhood trauma and that people with low self-esteem tend to see the world as a hostile place.
To combat low self-esteem, there are many things you can do. Read over these lists on a regular basis. Do more things that you enjoy. Look for positive role models. Look for people in your life who can contribute to raising your self-esteem, such as others who have conquered a difficulty with their body image. Such people can give you encouragement when you are tempted to feel bad about yourself.
Find a positive life balance. Finding a balance among school, work, rest, exercise, and social activities is important for feeling happy and maintaining a positive view of yourself. Take a moment to rework your schedule. If school is stressing you out, take more breaks. Start by dedicating one day a week like Saturday to not studying or thinking about your studies. Make sure you get enough sleep each night.
For teenagers ages 14 to 17, eight to 10 hours are needed; for adults 18 and up, seven to nine hours are necessary. Recognize the symptoms of bulimia. Knowing what to look for in yourself can help you determine if you need to seek help. For example, ask yourself questions to determine what your attitude towards food is. If it is a negative attitude that centers on guilt and shame for eating, you may be experiencing the beginnings of bulimia.
Go to source Ask yourself: Do I feel guilty after I eat? Do I throw up or take laxatives to keep from gaining weight? Do I eat until I feel ill on purpose? Am I obsessed with losing weight and with what I eat? Part 2. Be a role model. Demonstrate what a healthy and balanced lifestyle looks like. Show them how to have a balanced lifestyle and a balanced diet, as well as be available for them to talk to.
Avoid judging others. In order to be a strong role model, you need to stay approachable. One way to do this is to not be judgmental of others.
0コメント